At an lavish exclusive gathering hosted at Raffles establishment in central London this week, prominent figures of what is left within Tory circles celebrated the Spectator’s parliamentarian of the year awards.
With the magazine’s editorial line still just about backing the Tories, despite the party facing an existential crisis posed by Reform, it was unsurprising that much of the gossip at the champagne-fuelled event was about whether Kemi Badenoch’s job was at risk.
Party Tensions Emerge at Ceremony
One senior figure, who unsuccessfully ran, couldn’t resist a dig from the stage at the naked ambition of his shadow cabinet colleague, Robert Jenrick – who is Badenoch’s biggest threat.
“Am I after her job? Will I make a move against the leader and steal the crown? No, of course I’m not,” the experienced politician told the laughing audience while commencing the evening's proceedings.
The runner-up from last year, and has been pitching alarmingly to the right to take on Nigel Farage, did at least manage to chuckle. His own manoeuvres have been anything but subtle.
Countdown to Challenge Begins
Earlier this year, a dissatisfied MP set up a countdown clock online showing remaining time until Conservative rules allow leadership bids. That clock reaches zero this weekend.
At that point, opponents within the party will be able to submit letters to trigger a contest. Revised guidelines established recently raising the required support, meaning 30% of the party’s 119 MPs must endorse, previously just fifteen percent, establishing a tougher standard for potential challengers.
Potential Challengers and Backing
Is it feasible for opponents – primarily Jenrick – secure support from colleagues needed to initiate proceedings? Tory insiders point to the numbers who nominated him during the last race: 28 in the first round. “That’s your starting point,” they said.
There is no shortage of Tory MPs willing to share dissatisfaction with the leader: her style, her political judgment, her public appeal. However, generally, they are hesitant about committing yet another act a leadership overthrow so soon.
Respite and Election Concerns
Some Conservative MPs also believe the leader's conference address during the fall gathering, announcing a policy to remove property tax on primary homes, secured her a few months of breathing space.
“We might not be happy with Kemi’s leadership we will act cautiously regarding a change. Voters already perceive we fight like rats in a sack. We should avoid providing any more evidence of that,” an anonymous legislator stated.
This doesn't mean the plotting is not under way. “The leader has until spring. The local elections could be disastrous for the party. No one will desire to assume leadership preemptively and bear responsibility. But afterwards, we will need somebody capable of guiding toward renewal,” one shadow cabinet minister commented.
Polling Data and Public Opinion
Recent surveys indicate Badenoch has made little progress with the public in the past twelve months with declining in personal approval. With a negative score, her standing is lower compared to her rival and Mel Stride (-21), per recent polling.
Additional research also shows that Badenoch has convinced only 12% of Britons she is a prime minister in waiting. The outlook improves with party supporters, with 54% saying they approve of her performance in her role, with fewer than a third saying she should not lead the party into the next general election.
Future Possibilities and Party Dynamics
Despite mixed feelings among base voters, a general agreement exists among the MPs that Badenoch will not be the one to lead the party into the next election.
The main division is whether it would better to replace her in May to potentially halt Reform’s momentum – or leave it until closer to the general election when Farage might have imploded, and public receptiveness improves toward Conservative messages.
It is no secret that Jenrick thinks he is the man for the job. But his allies say he has no plans to move now, and is among those advocating patience until spring.
Other Contenders and Strategies
There is also a theory that the party’s potential saviour may end up being somebody less prominent figures (the shadow climate secretary Claire Coutinho gets mentioned) or among newer MPs without strong associations to the party’s time in power.
Cleverly, who came third, is also cited as a potentially unifying figure, remaining reserved. Supporters indicate he sees no better option but to carry on with Badenoch, as anybody taking over now would face greater challenges.
Should a race begin, some would certainly urging Cleverly to stand, and he might reconsider to give it another shot. A small group of centrist MPs are already preparing a rearguard action to block the frontrunner from winning.
Rightward Shift and Political Considerations
A well-connected Tory cautioned that momentum favors right-wingers within and beyond the Conservative party, mentioning names like Jenrick, Neil O’Brien, Katie Lam and Nick Timothy. “It is a chance for James given his experience and membership connections, while others oppose Jenrick at any costs.”
“Many are considering are on the need for a pact or coalition with Reform eventually. Recent parliamentary divisions regarding social issues there was a lot of ‘we need to kick the people who voted for those out the party’ and Reform’s private messaging is ‘you’ve got some Lib Dems you’d have to get rid of’. That tips things the challenger slightly.”
Yet another source noted: “Jenrick winning is not uncertain. We could have a strong competition between Jenrick and another – other prominent figures. The assumption that conservatives always wins the membership is not necessarily the case.”